Ruminations on the state of music, bands, technology, town and country and anything else that takes my fancy
Showing posts with label Miley Cyrus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miley Cyrus. Show all posts
Friday, 4 February 2011
Why I Loathe X-Factor ....
..Britain's Got Talent, Strictly Come Dancing and the like.
You may think it's because of Simon Cowell or Louis "Child Catcher" Walsh. To be honest, I think Simon Cowell is a media genius, manipulative, but he knows his stuff inside out. Walsh, though I find it very creepy.
You may think it's because of the policy of riding on some one else's shirt tails , only using covers of recent successes , Alexandra Burke's lip-trembling sub Whitney performance of Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah" , which contains the appropriate line "You Don't Really Care for Music , Do Ya?" . The song song was poignantly coversed by John Cale for Shrek , then there's the Jeff Buckley version and of course the original , but hey we need to make a safe fast buck.
The you had Joe McElderry cover Miley Cyrus with The Climb , and the latest installment Matt Cardle's saccharined treatment of Biffy Clyro's "Many A Horror" renamed for the Christmas market as When We Collide.
No it's not this , it's the fact that all the shows focus primarily on failure . One person is voted out every week and made to feel that they are a failure , and the last man standing is the winner , but the shows focus on getting rid of people . Appropriate for the current goverment set up, who are relishing making as many people redundant as possible.
Talent shows in the past focussed on people winning and there would be a number of contestants , one winner and the ones who didnt win , as a whole went back to their day jobs , without any stigma, they just didnt cut it.
If X-Factor focussed on winning then I would have time for it , but until then I wont be watching.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)